How to Solve Poverty in Colorado | CrossPurpose CEO Jason Janz
The Bear RoarsNovember 10, 202601:21:5975.06 MB

How to Solve Poverty in Colorado | CrossPurpose CEO Jason Janz

Jason Janz co-founded CrossPurpose, a Denver nonprofit that helps families climb out of poverty through job training, credentials and wealth building. Over 15 years it has grown to about 3,000 families a year across four Denver-area campuses. About 2,000 of its graduates now earn their own living, and together they’ve earned $200 million. Jason’s own family came to Colorado in 1985 with nothing after his dad’s business collapsed, and they moved into a friend’s basement. His new book, Together We Climb, co-written with Dr. Steven C. Taylor, lays out a community-driven approach to ending poverty.


Dan and Jason walk through the book’s four-step mountain: give a fish, teach to fish, provide a good fishing pole and own the pond. Most public money stops at the bottom of the mountain. Jason explains the benefits cliff, where a raise can leave a working parent no better off once their food stamps and housing help disappear. His answer is middle-skills jobs. 60% of Colorado jobs need a credential, not a degree, and CrossPurpose can get someone there in months. The new Workforce Pell program now pays for those short programs, but only when 70% of students finish and 70% get placed in jobs. Most colleges can’t hit that bar. Dan sees a business opportunity and offers to back entrepreneurs who can build it.


Plus, why condo lawsuits have stalled starter homes in Colorado, why Dan worries Amendment 87 will push jobs out of the state, and Dan’s offer to help launch a CrossPurpose chapter in Boulder.


Learn more about CrossPurpose: https://www.crosspurpose.org


Order Together We Climb: https://togetherweclimb.org


Order Dan's book — Bandwidth: The Untold Story of Ambition, Deception, and Innovation that Shaped the Internet Age and Dot-Com Boom: dan-caruso.com/book


Listen to Dan’s song Stretch: https://distrokid.com/hyperfollow/dancaruso/stretch


Check out music by Jason Mendelson (Jace Allen): https://www.youtube.com/@jaceallen


To nominate a founder or yourself as a future guest speaker, email: contact@loudbearproductions.com

[00:00:00] Jason Janz. Yes, sir. This is the first time we're meeting, and I did this at times where the podcast is with someone that I kind of sort of beat quickly over an email introduction that sounds interesting. And I like to learn about the topic and the person through conversations, so it kind of covers both my personal interests and the area that you're in, as well as sharing it with a broader audience. Thank you.

[00:00:25] You are Colorado, and one of the big themes of this podcast is people are doing innovative and interesting and compelling things in the state of Colorado that matter to people, and you're definitely fit in that category. You also have a book that you're going to share with us that is about to be published, which is going to be interesting. And I want to start with making a couple points. One is, I think, I don't know you, but I think you care deeply about humans. Very true.

[00:00:54] And in particular, you're focused on people in Colorado and maybe people who are in, for whatever variety of reasons, in less advantaged kind of circumstances. So, and then I want to make a statement in that I, too, care deeply about humans. I, too, care deeply about, particularly about those in Colorado because it's our community, not because I think Colorado is better than somewhere else in the world,

[00:01:21] but, you know, Colorado is where, like you, I have an opportunity to have more of an impact than if, you know, if I cast a much wider net. And I care deeply about those in Colorado having opportunities that are available to them for them to, you know, to build better lives for themselves and their families and their, you know, micro communities within Colorado. So, I enter this thinking that you and I have a lot in common.

[00:01:51] Yeah, that's 100% alignment right there. I think I would, when I care about humans, I also have a high sensitivity to human suffering. And so, my mission is to help solve poverty, but poverty, in my view, is basically human suffering. If you're living in your car with your one-year-old, you know, that's a life of suffering. And I don't want to live in a state where anybody has to live like that. And so, and then Colorado is also the state that gave me a second chance.

[00:02:19] They're, you know, my parents, my dad had a business in the Midwest that collapsed and we had nothing and moved out here. I was 11 years old. We knew one family in this city. She was a flight attendant for United. And our family moved into her basement. My dad restarted his business. My mom went to work at the airlines. Us kids took on paper routes and things like that. And, you know, from 1985 until now, I've been a Colorado kid. And I want to give back as much as possible to the state and the people that are here. Great.

[00:02:49] So, now I'm going to talk about how I suspect we're going to have some differences. And the differences are not in what we care about. Although I would say, you know, we all have more emphasis in how we bring what we care about, you know, where we think we'd have more of an impact, where we're able to exert more energy and passion. So, I think there's some differences there.

[00:03:11] But I think where we're going to find other differences is how you go about impacting in a positive way the journey of those who, you know, are in kind of the sector that you most are attentive to. There won't be big differences, but there'll be important differences to flesh out.

[00:03:34] But I think it's important to establish as we begin to have that conversation, it's not because of where we're coming from and inside. It may be more because, you know, I've seen the world from a different perspective than you. You've seen the world from a different perspective than me. And there's probably merit in kind of both the way we think about it and we're going to explore that. And I think that's what's going to make this particularly interesting for me and hopefully interesting for others as well.

[00:04:00] So, and we'll come back and talk more about your background and how you got to where you got. But let's jump right into your book. Let's hit that right out of here. So, we'll hit the book and then we'll hit what you're doing now. And then we'll learn more about you more as we navigate our way through this. So, tell us, I think you got a copy of the book? Yeah, the book is... Do you want to show it to the camera? The book is called Together We Climb.

[00:04:23] And it's essentially an innovative model that came out of the dirt here in Colorado on a new way to approach a solution to American poverty. So, there's a basic framework that we use. We use a mountain as the metaphor because we're from Colorado. And I do tend to like this state, you know, better than most. But there's really... When we talk about getting people out of poverty, most people always think about essential needs. Like, let's give people food, clothing, and shelter.

[00:04:50] But I think our vision is poor if that's all, the further we go. So, when I talk on poverty, people say, we don't believe in just giving someone a fish. We want to teach them to fish. Well, I think that gets people only halfway there. They need a good job. You can't just educate people. And with only like a third of college grads going into their field of study, like, I think we need a lot of work on how we're teaching to fish. But then we need good places for people to go. And so, I think the number one... Let me jump in on that one because what's really interesting about...

[00:05:19] As we sit here right now and are recording this, we don't know the outcome of a really important measure that was on the ballot yesterday. It's Amendment 87. And Amendment 87 is slightly ahead. And it's more likely not as we sit here that it's going to pass versus not pass.

[00:05:42] And I think that will be the biggest destroyer of opportunity for Coloradoans in, you know, in the two and a half decades, coming close to three decades that I've been here in Colorado. It is going to be the most harmful in robbing, you know, Coloradoans, you know, including and maybe especially, you know, of the demographic that you're describing, of their opportunities in the future.

[00:06:09] Yet it got, you know, it got about 50% support. So either 50% slightly more, in which case it's going to pass, or slightly less, in which case it's not going to pass. And that's, I think, an example of an area where my guess is, you know, you looked at that amendment through a different lens, then I wouldn't look through it.

[00:06:31] And I look at it as a big destroyer of opportunity for Coloradoans and a big creator of opportunity for people in Texas and Arizona and Florida and elsewhere. Are you familiar with Amendment 87? You're talking about the graduated income tax? Yeah. Yeah, I do believe it's going to be harmful to business. I mean, we're supported by business, and we've got a thousand businesses employ our graduates.

[00:06:56] And so I do think outside businesses looking in, you know, your C-suites and your owners, I think, are going to take a different look at this. I think we're now going to be the sixth highest, like, state tax bracket in the country. And then I think it's also, like, there are a lot of people here that have been successful, that are giving back to this community, that are thinking about moving out.

[00:07:20] I mean, really practically, you know, our organization has a couple of donors, and, you know, one of them just moved to Texas just for this reason, wanting to get in front of it. Really? Can you say who that was, or would you rather not? I'd rather not say that. Can you guys find out who that is via the internet? Yeah.

[00:07:40] So I definitely think that there, I don't know, I tend to, you know, we're supported as an organization by people who've been successful, who are trying to give back to a community. So I actually see all sides of it. Well, let me add a couple more sides to it, because you mentioned, too, one, corporate leaders are going to view Colorado differently. You know, they certainly, if they're not here and they're looking to move, they're not going to come here.

[00:08:09] You know, there might be an exception or two if Colorado, you know, has some kind of deep affinity with the company. But for the most part, you know, they aren't coming here, which means their jobs aren't coming here with them. And then you mentioned some people who have been successful. A lot of people are on their arc of success are going to be highly incented to leave as well. And with them is going to be the jobs that, you know, are within their entities as well.

[00:08:32] But also all of the economic activity that goes along with those types of corporations and those types of people being in Colorado, all the retail spending on restaurants, on hospitality, you know, that's going to go away. And I think, you know, when you look back four years from now, tax revenue is going to be down, not up. It's certainly going to be up in a year or two when the change is first made, because it takes time for corporations to move and people to avoid coming here for that to have a big effect.

[00:09:02] But in all those areas, it affects opportunities. I mean, it affects opportunities in everyday jobs, which are really important, you know, keeping the restaurants and retail and hospitality healthy. You know, I think it's going to negatively affect tax revenue over time. And I think immediately it's going to affect real jobs and real companies that, you know, have to move elsewhere. And then you mentioned this one thing that I didn't even focus on.

[00:09:29] When they go to support the nonprofit sector, which, you know, I've got a foundation called the Crucible Foundation. We certainly write checks. I'm going to stay in Colorado. I'm not going to leave for this reason. But, you know, if I did leave, I guarantee you my giving would shift from Colorado to wherever I go to. And, you know, those people are leaving, that same thing's going to happen.

[00:09:50] And it's just shocking to me that we willingly, not just as voters, but as the leaders who are advising those voters what to vote for, that we could have gotten this thing either passed or really dangerously close to being passed without, you know, fully realizing the opportunity and the demographic that you care most about.

[00:10:15] Well, and this model does not work without a flourishing employment private sector. I mean, they employ 85 out of 100 Coloradans. So, like, if they're not flourishing, people aren't getting out of poverty because they're not getting good wages, they're not getting good jobs. So the model we have is we're all accountable to each other to make the system work. And so when you overly load one system with trying to make everything work, it's going to make it difficult. So I like that expression, we're all accountable to one another.

[00:10:44] Let's focus on that a little bit more because I think that is absolutely, you know, appropriate, essential. But you don't hear people use those words very often. So talk more about that. How do you see people being accountable to one another? Again, I believe in those words. I think if you look at society, there's a social contract that happens where we tend to all believe we want to live in a state where somebody who is on hard times, we're going to help them out a little bit. People will say a little bit or a lot.

[00:11:14] There's differences on that. But there's this social contract that we're going to take care of people that need some help. So we have a safety net here that works with people. The understanding is that those are on the safety net. There's a social contract saying if we're going to help you out, we want you to also work for yourselves and get to a point where you can support yourselves. So then we give them that kind of leg up and we want them to go and get the education necessary and get a good job. And then we want employers, when they employ people, say give them a good job.

[00:11:40] Let's not just treat them like widgets, but let's think about a benefits package. I mean, the largest builder of wealth in this state are employers. And the largest social contract is between an employer and employee because they're both helping each other win. And that partnership can last 5, 10, 20 years and help them build wealth and buy a home. So even as a nonprofit, I stand in front of our students and say we're entering a social contract here. I've gone and talked to people in this state who want to invest in helping you get a credential so you can get a good job.

[00:12:10] But you've got to win because if you win, they'll support the next person sitting in your seat. So it's not just about whether... And so will you. Yeah, right. You will support the next person. 100%. In your community. And I think that social contract is underneath all of this stuff. And I think we talk... Can I add another group or two? You sort of alluded to this, but preparing our younger generation for being very productive.

[00:12:36] In whatever way they can be very productive in their job and career journey, that's another, I think, aspect of the social contract. It's our responsibility as those who are maybe at a different stage of life, but regardless of your demographic, to look back and say, I want that next generation to give them every opportunity to be successful. And I need these other groups that you mentioned to do their part.

[00:13:05] It's like you said, we've all got to lean in together. But we also need to make sure they get a really good education because if they get a shitty education, then you're kind of asking people to carry them, go out of their way to find jobs that have really good pay, even though it's hard for them to deliver value in exchange for that. And I think the system breaks down with that because it's a big ask to ask for-profit organizations.

[00:13:31] I'm running a restaurant, and I want that restaurant to be profitable so that it could stay in business and so it could make payroll. And I want to hire people, and I want them to flourish in their jobs. But if I'm being asked to hire people who don't know how to do whatever job I need done in a restaurant, that's like, I'm not sure I can do that because then my restaurant's likely to fail. I'm not going to hire someone to be a chef that pays a higher amount than something else who doesn't know how to be a good chef. That's just not something I'm going to do.

[00:14:01] And I think we sometimes maybe underemphasize how our education system is not up to snuff. And the answer isn't, well, let's just go spend more money on education because it's not that we don't spend a lot. It's that when we spend a lot of money and don't deliver kind of a good education, I mean, it's really hard to get ahead. You know, there's a question in football that I think it's used more now than it was used five years ago.

[00:14:30] And you'll stay ahead of the chains, you know, meaning make positive yards so that if it's second down, it's, you know, not second and 14. It's second and six. And it's third and two so that you're moving the ball forward. But if you start by, you know, producing a really bad education for particularly those in, you know, in more, you know, kind of difficult, you know, circumstances, you know, you've already put them 10 yards behind, you know, behind the scrimmage.

[00:14:58] And now they've got to do a fourth and 20 to get even a big, keep the drive going. And we just seem to, it befuddles me that we can't, you know, figure that out more. Yeah, one of the biggest gaps, and I think most people don't see it, is we have a K-12 system that the public believes in and the public funds. We have a higher ed system that the public generally believes in and the public funds through Pell Grants and loans and things like that.

[00:15:25] But 60% of Colorado jobs are middle skills jobs. They're not high skills or not entry skills like at the restaurant. Those 60% of middle skills do not need a two or four year degree. They just need a credential or some kind of training. We have no public institution that serves that gap. Half of all seniors, I think it's 8,000 seniors coming out of Denver Title I low-income schools will never go to a day of college. 8,000 a year.

[00:15:55] Well, they can go get a credential that takes between a month and nine months to get. And they can get a job at $60,000 to $75,000 a year. But our nonprofit exists because there's no public institution that allows that. And so you go to the community college and say, why don't you guys offer credentials instead of a two-year degree? Well, if you're in the business, would you sell a $20,000 two-year product or would you sell a $4,000 six-month product? Right? And the public is going to help you fund the two-year product.

[00:16:23] So there's no incentive to actually credentialize. So I just think that's a massive gap because there's 200,000 resident undergrads in Colorado schools right now. Half of them will not go on and finish a four-year degree. A third of the graduates only will actually go into their field of study. So you could say we've a little bit oversold the four-year degree.

[00:16:48] We have 100,000, 150,000 open jobs and we have 200,000 kids in college, half of which will not work in their career field. We just do the math, right? They could have went and got a credential, not put themselves in debt, and then thought, what career do I really want? Because most of them at 18 don't know what they want to do. So I think we've invested in education, but I don't think we've done the right investment at the right place to provide these ladders for people to be successful. All right, let me pause you there because I want to spend a lot more time on that topic, but I interrupted you when you were talking about your book.

[00:17:18] So I want to first get back to your book, then I want to talk about your organization, then I want to go deeper into what you're talking about right now. Well, the four steps on the mountain is give a fish, then you teach to fish, then you equip them with a good fishing pole, which we just talked about. The last one, though, is we want them to own the pond where they need to actually be able to pass on generational wealth to their family. And I'm not talking transformational wealth like yachts and things like that. I'm talking about foundational wealth where you can pass on at least $50,000 to your kids.

[00:17:48] If the bottom half of the country passes on $9,000 at their death, 51% to 90% pass on $47K. 91% to 99% pass on $250,000, and the upper 1% passes on about $750,000. So if our families can get to $50,000 of net assets that they pass on, they're in the top 10% of the American economy. Well, that says terrible things about our economy. But it does say we should be able to get people there in the state of Colorado.

[00:18:15] If we can get them to the point where they can buy a home and start investing in their retirement in their 20s and early 30s, they will do fine in this state. So that's the four-step model. And my heartbeat around poverty is we need to have that whole vision for our neighbors, not just let's help them with food and clothing and stop there. But that's where all the investment is. All the investment in the safety net is in the bottom of the mountain, not the top. Yeah. So, and I agree with all that, by the way.

[00:18:44] And I want to leave this conversation with some actionable ideas for me to take forward on how I can play more of a role in that because I haven't really – I've done a lot of things to contribute, but I haven't done enough to contribute in that particular area. So let's break down your four steps. Step number one. Give a fish. That's essential needs. Food, clothing, and shelter for people. Yep. So let's stay on that for a little bit.

[00:19:13] When do you give that? Like what are the circumstances? What are the boundaries on that in your – Yeah. There's about a quarter million Coloradans living underneath the federal poverty guidelines, single mom with one kid, making less than about $15,000, $16,000 a year. There's another working poor class that would double that amount, triple that amount. We call them ALICE. They're asset-limited, income-constrained, but employed. That's a great thing.

[00:19:40] So just think, you know, 35% of the state struggles on a paycheck-to-paycheck level. And so the federal government has a safety net, you know, over 100 different programs, usually eight core ones around all the core issues of food and clothing and shelter and childcare that we help people with when they're on that bottom of the ladder and they just can't get ahead and just give them some aid to kind of move forward. So that's kind of the public safety net. There's also like, you know, this invisible safety net. Let me pause.

[00:20:10] Because there's – again, I enter this with I think everyone I know, and there's probably some exceptions here or there, whether they're a D or an R or an independent, you know, care about having a safety net for those, you know, who need it. But I also know that there's wildly different views about, you know, what that really means, the extensiveness of it, the methods in which you do it.

[00:20:38] But, you know, some – you know, if you're on our side of the house, you think that a lot of the way it's done kind of perpetuates the problem or maybe even makes you scratch your head. Like is that – like let me give an example here in Boulder. You know, affordable housing is a big deal in Boulder and it seems like the affordable housing is often, you know, a detriment to making living more affordable. You know, and they do it in ways at times.

[00:21:05] Like there's a project that the city got control of. They're building their fancy new offices on this nice piece of land that is right in the foothills. And they took a piece of that land and they're going to make it affordable housing. Well, that's about the most expensive affordable housing that you could design.

[00:21:23] So if your goal was really to help those in need, why would you have expended so much resource on so little housing on the most expensive place to build housing when there could have been – you could have helped, I don't know, five times the number of people if you, you know, if you took more of the position that we're going to find a place to do this

[00:21:48] where, you know, the – where we're managing toward kind of helping as many people in need as we can with the limited dollars. You know, there's – you know, so I see lots of examples of that and say, okay, is that really people who are, you know, who are doing a, you know, an effective job of using public resource to help those in need or is there something else going on there? Yeah, I think that I use the metaphor – first of all, the metaphor of the safety net is essentially from the circus

[00:22:18] and the trapeze artists. And you have this net underneath them so that when they fall, they don't hit the concrete, right? Well, the R side of the aisle says we need to shrink that net and make it smaller. The D side, they say let's – the net needs to be bigger and there's a bunch of holes in the net. We need to fix the net. Nobody's really saying – I haven't met anybody who wants to live in a net, right? Trapeze artists, they want to soar through the air and get that adrenaline pumping.

[00:22:43] And so I think we need to start by saying let's create a plan that gets people back up the ladder in doing what they're called to do and there's just too much focus on that net. We all think the net should be there. We can disagree about the size of it. The other metaphor – I think a lot more of the disagreement is not on the size of it. It's on the nature of it. It's like how do you do what you described? How do you do it in a way that, you know, some people are just going to, you know, in a more permanent way need help, right? I mean, that's a reality of the world we're always going to live in.

[00:23:13] But there is another, I think, superset of the people who if the help was more thoughtfully designed, they would have more of a chance of kind of doing what you described. I think that's where the disagreement often lies. During the New Deal, we had our largest injection of public funds. Social Security, all that stuff began in the New Deal.

[00:23:36] Then Johnson's War on Poverty in the 60s was the second major infusion of public cash into basic human needs. But it wasn't set up in a way that I think helps the average neighbor. I mean, it's in eight different departments at the Fed. Like food stamps are in the Department of Agriculture, right? HUD is over here. Well, then when someone's on benefits, they actually have different ways that if they make more money, they lose benefits. It's everybody's for, we don't want them permanently on benefits, but they're now, they're called the benefits cliffs.

[00:24:05] So you could give the person in the restaurant a $2 an hour raise and she might lose $6,000 a year in food stamps because you gave her that raise. So we have benefits cliffs versus benefits slopes. And we don't have a coordinated way to, every single program has a different cliff. And the single mom does not know where the cliffs are, nor does the social worker, by the way. Now, tech can give us a great way now. There's a bunch of tools. We've created one to help them navigate those cliffs.

[00:24:31] So we say, hey, you know, for instance, a single mom with two kids, there's no difference between her making $18 an hour and $29 an hour when she hits all those cliffs. So the system itself has disincentivized her. Yeah. Let's make sure we understand that. So between $18 and $29. It's flat. In fact, sometimes they'll actually go down because they'll lose their food stamps or their Section 8 voucher and have to pay full rent. And they're excited because they've got a raise. Yeah, you equated that to a raise.

[00:24:59] I assume that also is based on how much income you're making in total. So that also is if you work more hours. You're essentially penalized for moving ahead. You're getting paid zero. And I can't, yeah, exactly. And I can't tell the Fed the changes. They see the problem. But you have to, like, really remanufacture the entire system. What we can do to the mom is say, you shouldn't go for a $22 an hour job.

[00:25:22] We need to get you credentialed for a $30 an hour job so you can jump this cliff and, like, really get a job and not be disincentivized and discouraged on your career journey. Yeah. And I know you can't, you know, nor can I affect the complexity of how the federal government does it. But people we let can, you know, people we let can be talking about that.

[00:25:46] They could be saying, hey, you know, here's something, you know, we, the R's and the D's can agree on that, you know, we've got a system that makes someone who is making a certain income, the equivalent of $17 an hour, all the way if you just measure it on dollars per hour through $29, that they're disincentive. Which means, you know, the system is broken. And why don't we fix it? You know, but I've never heard a politician talk about that. Have you?

[00:26:13] Well, I think more of them are aware that the system is broken. But our state officials don't have the power to fix the Fed problem, right? So I sit here as a neighbor and go, well, I still know that the person I'm working with today is in poverty. And I'm not waiting on Washington to save us, even though they need to go fix this. So let's figure out how to coach people through that. But we've got representatives in Washington I'm friends with, Senator Bennett and Senator Hickenlooper. And we've got a governor who wants to be a leader in Washington, a new governor.

[00:26:44] I never hear them talking about that. Shouldn't they be? Yeah. I mean, Utah is actually pioneering a very new way of doing this called the one-door policy, where a citizen can walk in, go to one application, one door, and access all benefits. And they can be intelligently distributed and given out. They have a waiver from the federal government. There's like six other states that want to go that way, which would greatly streamline it. I think there are some policy people on the Hill that are looking at empowerment accounts, as opposed to all these different benefits pools with different rules,

[00:27:14] where every citizen gets a certain amount upon birth into this country that will help them during a hard time. But they can use it intelligently for what they need, because it's really hard for a public system to actually treat their citizens with an individualized case plan that helps them at the time. So what you're talking about is really broken on so many levels. Yeah, and hard to fix. But also, you know, a lot of white flags get raised like, I don't want to talk about this, I want to talk about something that's totally...

[00:27:42] I think that's why, though, when you look at the problem of poverty, it's not very hard to figure out why someone in poverty, they don't have money. So we've got to solve the money problem. So you're going to give it to people, or they're going to have to work for it, right? And I have the opinion that we'll help them with a bum leg for a period of time and a bad ankle, but we want them standing on their own, so we want to give them a good job so they can work and make money. So I didn't take public transportation here. I don't live in affordable housing.

[00:28:11] I don't go to food banks. Why? Because I have an income that allows me not to do that. So if we're going to solve poverty, let's start there. Let's get people great jobs with great benefits, and then they're off the net, right? They're off the entire system. And I don't meet a lot of people that actually want to be on public assistance. It's a shameful thing for them. They get judged by society, and they want to have the dignity of work and provide for their family and take their kids to Disneyland, and I want that too. Yeah. Yeah.

[00:28:41] And I think maybe on that point, I definitely agree with that, but with maybe a little bit more of an asterisk or two, and that is if you disincentivize people from doing that extra work, which we just talked about kind of a prime example of that, it could be true that they'd rather not be in that circumstance, but it could also be true that they're like,

[00:29:08] but I'm not stupid either, and I feel pretty stupid if I'm going to work more hours and make the same amount of money that I would make otherwise, so I'm not going to work more hours because that makes me feel like I'm, you know, when my social group is making just as much of me and doesn't have to work those extra hours. I'd rather not work those extra hours and do something else if I'm effectively not going to get compensated for that.

[00:29:36] So we're kind of like almost talking out of both sides of our mouth by, I think, you know, again, I agree that people don't want and they don't choose to be in those circumstances, but then we set up a system that gives them an incentive to stay in those circumstances because of what they might have to do to overcome that doesn't feel right either. Yeah, when you have a system that disincentivizes progress, you have a broken system.

[00:30:06] Yeah. And we have a broken system. Okay, let's get to your next level. I've harped on that a while, so let's get to number two now. So number two is teach the fish. Like if we're going to get them to a livable wage job in this state, which I think you need about $25 to $27 an hour to be able to afford an apartment, food and clothing and transportation. What's that a year roughly? I just double it. So $25 is about $50,000 a year. $27 is like $54,000 a year.

[00:30:34] And so in order for them to get there is what I was saying about the middle skills. They often need some form of training or credentialing to be able to get a job that pays that because you're not going to pay an entry-level restaurant worker $27 an hour usually. So the good news is that's where we specialize is looking at middle skills jobs with short-term credentials. So, for instance, if you want to go work in health care, most people think that we work with families in poverty, so we teach the trades. They only think of the trades in plumbers.

[00:31:04] It's like, well, half of our grades are health care, and health care is a huge employer in this state. And so you can be a certified nurse assistant or a medical assistant or someone in medical billing and coding and start in that $22 to $25 an hour now at Anschutz Hospital over on Colfax. So they can get that credential in about four months. So when you think of that, they're actually outperforming two-year college degrees on income upon exit.

[00:31:31] Well, now for a couple grand, they now have a lower middle-class job with benefits, and they've got oxygen back in their life. And that's just a speed to market. Like, we can get them there in six months versus the average two-year degree in Colorado is taking 4.7 years to complete. And so it's just not a great solution right now to actually get people out of poverty. But you have entry-level jobs in tech. You have entry-level jobs in the trades.

[00:31:57] Just truck drivers in this state, we'll train 110 truck drivers this year. They'll start between $60,000 and $80,000 a year just running back and forth to Wyoming. So that's where I'm saying, okay, let's get your job first, and let's talk about college second. And maybe if you want to go there. Let's pause there for a second because you mentioned something earlier about how community colleges, as an example,

[00:32:21] are disincented to provide that type of education because they're able to make more money by convincing people that they need to get a two-year, four-year degree. Why are those who help make it such that community colleges can get paid, why are they not onto this and say, we need to change the incentive system?

[00:32:45] Because I assume community colleges exist in large part because of government support of the students that go to them or otherwise. So how would you, if you had a magic wand and said you need to redesign kind of how we compensate for... Yeah, so if you're running, just let's think if you're running education like a business, you can get about $7,400 a year in a Pell Grant per year per student.

[00:33:12] So if you get your cost below that, you've got a self-sufficient model. And so a two-year degree would be about $15,000 that the federal government would give you if you took a low-income person into your school. Well, there was zero public funding for the credential. You only got it for the two-year degree. Well, for 10 years in the Congress, they've been trying to get Workforce Pell passed. Well, the Pell lobby didn't want that because you're going to rob the two-year degree and the four-year degree of the Pell money.

[00:33:41] Well, last year in H.R. 1, Workforce Pell passed as part of that huge package that the red team put through. Well, the red team, they're all about... Wait, the red team? Isn't that Trump? Yes. I thought Trump just did horrible things. That didn't sound so horrible. That was pretty bipartisan, actually, that people wanted that to go through. So it got through. It was 10 years. That bill was stalled. Why did you call it the red team? I call it red team, blue team just because that's the...

[00:34:11] No, but I mean, why did you give credit to the red team? Well, because they got H.R. 1 passed. I mean, they were in power when that bill passed. But what they did is because... And what all did H.R. 1 cover? I think it's called the one big beautiful bill. Oh, that's what's the one, yeah. It did all the Medicaid cuts, all the stuff, all the tax cuts. This was just kind of stuck in there and passed through. True. And for that specific measure, if it was in a standalone bill, who would have been supporting

[00:34:40] that specific measure? I actually don't know. I do know it was stalled for 10 years and everyone was frustrated that they couldn't get it through. And I was kind of surprised that it got tucked in there. But to your point on incentivizing, the red team designed Workforce Pell. Well, what they said, they said, we're tired of there being no accountability in the system. So they said, if you're going to get it, you have to be an accredited institution. We want quality, right?

[00:35:06] Number two, you have to have 70% course completion to get the Pell dollars. And you have to have 70% job placement to get the Pell dollars. Well, that actually sounds awesome, right? We now have accountability that the public's going to give money and they're not going to throw it down the drain. Because the dirty little secret of community colleges is, you know, one of the closest ones just has a 16% graduation rate. There's no accountability for the Pell dollar on the two and four year side.

[00:35:35] Well, the two and four year colleges do not have that accountability. They're not giving Pell dollars based on 70% job placement and 70% program completion. So then higher ed walked up to Workforce Pell and said, nah, because they only get $4,300 for a Workforce Pell certificate. So now, because you put accountability into this part of the system, but you didn't put it into the whole system.

[00:36:01] Now those, I mean, Colorado approved like four programs like to do the Workforce Pell thing because it's just not worth it. Because higher ed knows they cannot meet the 70-70 accountability metric. So once again, low income people get screwed because now we have a- Why wouldn't like new startups go after that? That seems like a perfect opportunity for someone to come in and say, you know, innovator's dilemma. The established institutions are going to ignore that opportunity. But we're not.

[00:36:31] We're going to take advantage of the opportunity and we're going to design something that- No, I think it's a great point. It is a great point because I believe when you now have a- basically a publicly funded opportunity, if you can run something- But even like if you did a for-profit model, they get so chastised being in the public education sector. But I don't- I'm not- I'm ambivalent about for-profit- What do you mean by that? Well, a lot of for-profit universities have become bad actors and have taken advantage of

[00:37:00] things and charge people, extrovert them amounts, get them into debt. And so there's a kind of a feeling in the public sector at least against- Well, not-for-profit ones do the same thing. Oh, I know, but- Right? So I don't know if that's unique to for-profit. That's like being the for-profit. It's like, well, let's talk about the not-for-profit education system and the shitty job they do. Oh, believe me, I don't think there's anything more righteous about a for-profit or non-profit. I think it's just a model. I mean, non-profit is a tax status. It's not a business model.

[00:37:28] So, yeah, I do think there could be opportunity there, but you're going to have to run a business model that the price point is under $4,300 a person. And you can do that, by the way. Yes. So my hope is you could have- Especially with AI help. Yeah. Hell, how might I do that? Yeah. I mean, it's why- If anyone wishes and wants to take a shot at it and, you know, and they know what they're doing, I'll bank it.

[00:37:55] I mean, I think it would be awesome if you had really smart people coming in saying, let's go into this space. And I think you're going to face some headwinds, but it's a guaranteed government-funded entitlement. What's the headwinds? What's that? What's the headwinds? Well, you'd have to get to become an accredited institution or piggyback off of one. I think, secondly- Well, I would think the state of Colorado would want to work with- I agree.

[00:38:25] You know, and let's say a good actor. So if they knew it was a good actor, meaning someone whose intentions are in the right place, and they said, we want to create an accredited institution to do exactly this, I would think the state of Colorado would be all over it and would want to work with- Yeah. And say, what do we need to do to try to make this successful?

[00:38:51] Yeah, I think because, and this is, you know, as a business guy, marketing would be key because the public doesn't see this really as its own sector. And like I say- I'm an entrepreneur, and that sounds like opportunity to me. I know. I know. I agree. I mean, the education system is being disrupted already. And the institutions are on their heels because in 10 years, I don't think you're going to recognize higher ed very much because of AI, VR, all that stuff that's happening.

[00:39:20] And this is an opportunity. I mean, there are 200 Silicon Valley companies working on like VR-type solutions for skills training and all that kind of stuff. The price point is going to keep going down. Yes. In fact, I can tell you this story, but I had a man come interview for a job with me and he was hired by one of the local universities. And they said, hey, we know we're behind the times. We need to get in front of it. Let's go find a low-cost program that we could do.

[00:39:45] And so he went out and found you can get cybersecurity on VR goggles in your bedroom, basically, and get a credential and get a $70,000 job. And so we went back to the university and said, this is it. And the board said, okay, let's approve $2 million to start this program. What's the price point of the tuition? It was $500. Well, they shot themselves in the foot, right? Because they're no longer selling a $20,000 to $100,000 product. They're selling a $500 product. It's better for the community, but it's not good for the institution.

[00:40:15] Well, that's the innovator's dilemma. I know. It wasn't good for the IBM institution when Apple came along, was it? I'm all for it. Believe me, I am all for it. Like, if we had good actors that were smart that could think with a business mind, it would disrupt the sector, not by poking it in the eye, just by creating something better, cleaner, cheaper. Leapfrog them. Say, you go do what you do, and good luck. 100%. We'll see how you survive 10 years from now.

[00:40:40] But in the meantime, we're going to collect all that new money that the government wants to spend, and we're going to meet those thresholds, and we're going to do good for society. Yeah. Almost every company I know needs entry-level talent, middle skills talent, and high-skilled talent. This middle sector is just impoverished because there's not actors in there to do it at scale and volume. All right. Well, let's see if I can get anyone to send me a note and say, I want to build a business, and I'm capable.

[00:41:10] You've got to be capable of making it successful. We need 20 of them. I mean, 20 of them would be awesome. Yeah. Yeah. And it's so scalable when you know you've got at least a certain price point baked in from the public. Yep. You need 20 of them, or you need one that has 20 branches. Yeah. But you need a successful one for other people to copy. Yep. Cool. So we got to number two. That's number two. Or is that number three? Number three is equip with a good fishing pole.

[00:41:35] So that is, higher ed's not accountable that their graduate from CU is going to go get a job. They just train them and say, good luck, right? Well, they sort of train them. You know, I'm not talking about CU, but, you know, as we could talk a lot about, including the Harvards of the world. It's like, are you training them to get a good job? Or are you just like, you know, I don't know, doing something else, you know, entertaining them for four years?

[00:42:00] And, you know, knowingly that, you know, the majority of the people who are going through your school are going to realize they've got a lot more debt than they're going to have an income to compensate for the debt. Yeah. So are you really, you know, focused on preparing them as an educational institution? Or have you lost your way of that? And I think, you know, I think it's fair to say a lot of the educational institutions, you know, don't have the right balance right now. Well, yeah, I think AI is going to change it because they can't.

[00:42:27] I mean, my son, I mean, I have a son that graduated from CU Boulder, but then I have a son who loved motorsports. And he went out to one of the biggest, you know, motorsports universities in the country. And three quarters of the way through his freshman year, his 62-year-old professor said, I want you to calculate the gear ratio on a manual transmission only using a calculator. And he pulled out his phone and went into AI and got it in five seconds. And he said, Dad, I'm not going to pay 25 grand a year for this. I'm coming home. Yeah. Right? And now he's building AI websites for businesses, right?

[00:42:56] So I think that's going to happen all over the place. And it's not, I don't think higher ed is going to be able to correct fast enough to keep up with that, the value prop of what's really needed in the economy. Oh, I agree with you. That's where I think innovators, I mean, there's examples already. We got locally here, Magic School, a deal. I think I'm pretentious that right. It was on the podcast here, fascinating. And I understand that new AI school system. This is not for higher ed.

[00:43:22] It's for kind of, you know, earlier education that's been originating in Austin and is now expanding rapidly. I forget the name of it, but I hear they're going to open up one in Boulder and they're going to open up somewhere in South Denver as the first two in Colorado. And, yeah, that's going to be enormously disruptive and hopefully in an extraordinarily positive way for helping those in all demographics move ahead. So we want our families to get a good job.

[00:43:49] And there's a whole thing around what a good job is versus just a job. But I say basically, like, it's a good place to work. There's a good work environment and they get paid their value. And there's a benefits package that keeps them from there's a kind of insurance policy in their life that when things go bad, they've got a health insurance or they've got a 401k to fall back on. And so that's a good job. So our families, you know, most of them are coming from the struggle.

[00:44:17] And but I don't tell employers that we don't say make a charity hire. I think that's a losing ballgame. I'd say, yeah, you're going to compete on the market with everything they're getting from Indeed. And you're going to show up there. And that's why we do the job training. We put them in six weeks of soft skills. Then they get their credential. Then they do mock interviews. We get them ready for the interview so they can compete. And I don't even want the employer, you know, saying, oh, that's a cross-purpose graduate over there.

[00:44:44] Because I want them to shine and not have a label on their forehead that there's something, you know, unique about them or whatever. No, you're going to go into a labor pool and work on the 23rd floor as a legal intern and do a great job for that company. And your job is to help them make money. And then they're going to put food on your table. And what I challenge employers with is you are the largest wealth generator in American communities.

[00:45:09] And the people on your teams, like, think of your benefits package as a wealth building package. If you do just a matching 401k, a mid-20s, young 30s person can put a couple hundred bucks a month into a matching 401k and be a millionaire upon retirement. Most people don't know that. You know, we had 70 students in a class. I spoke to them. Not one of them had heard the words 401k. You show them the eighth wonder of the world of compound interest and they start saving. I mentored a woman last year.

[00:45:37] She saved $50,000 in one year just because she understood how components would help her in the future. So that, to me, is equipping them with a good fishing pole where they actually have a skill. And then, usually, if you get them into a good employer and they want to advance, there's these internal pathways. You know, Craig Hospital, where we probably put 25 medical assistants, will help pay for their tuition if they want to get a college degree.

[00:46:00] We now have a partner called Advance EDU where all of our grads can get a two- and four-year degree for free from one of three different universities, including CSU Global, in 40 different career paths. So we say, do career first, college second. Let's get the oxygen into your life and get a good job. So we need a private sector that is humming and healthy and ramping on talent in all three of those lanes of entry skill, middle skill, and high skill. Yep. All right.

[00:46:29] So, number four. Number four is own the pond. So, own the pond is thinking of a vision of the American dream for every colorado citizen where they can actually have ownership and build wealth. And, like, I told you, like, how hard that is. But I'm just – we just love people to the point where we say, we want that for you. I mean, I'm a follower of the teachings of Jesus when he said, love your neighbor as yourself. So that kind of is the roadmap.

[00:46:56] Like, the way I love myself is the way I want to love my neighbor. So if I want a reliable car, my neighbor probably does too. If I want a warm house to live in, they probably do too. So let's love them to where they can actually have that opportunity. Well, you know, there's a huge – there's 20 ways to build wealth. The three primary ways is owning a home, investing in your retirement, or starting a business. And you would know this, maybe 1% to 3% of the world should probably start a business. Now, we have a business –

[00:47:24] Starting a business is also a good way to destroy your wealth. Yeah, get into poverty. So, yeah, it's like the fastest way out of – the statistically proven fastest way out of poverty is actually marriage. Because now you have two incomes and you have two people. It's also a way into poverty if you do that wrong. So we focus on all three of those. So we have a business incubator where we take about five grads every year. And they basically move from an idea to a pitchable idea. And then we raise about $10,000 to $50,000 of capital for them to test out the idea.

[00:47:52] But for the other – the main track would be homeownership or investing in retirement. So we teach them about that. Homeownership is the way the average American is going to probably pass on wealth. Well, we have a huge problem in that Colorado, I say, is a broken system for that. I mean, the average Denver home is $600,000. The average Boulder home is $950,000. So that just becomes a massive gap for people to jump.

[00:48:19] And when the middle class can't afford to buy a home, you have a broken economy. Let's stay on that topic for a while. If you're on the East Coast or the West Coast, you've got land problems, right? It's very congested. It's very expensive to build. And they have high housing costs as well. So I look down and say, you know, they've got a significant challenge there.

[00:48:49] But they also have bigger hurdles that are hard to overcome to solve that problem. And then I come here to Colorado and I drive from Boulder to Denver. And all I see is places where you could have homes. Yeah. I see them everywhere. And if I drive from here to the airport, I see even more places that have homes. And they're not far from, you know, where people would want to be. And they're just plentiful. It's like everywhere you look, homes could be built. There's land.

[00:49:18] And there's, you know, space. And there's, you know, close proximity to where you would want to be to have a job. So to me, I'm like, okay, we don't have the constraint that the Northeast would have or, you know, San Francisco Bay Area or LA Area would have. Yet our ability to have a supply of housing that is more affordable just seems to be an insurmountable problem.

[00:49:47] I'm like, how can that be so insurmountable? I am as befuddled as you are on this because I see the same thing. Just go by the airport. I mean, everywhere you go, you see land. And it's like, now there are people, there's a consortium of about a dozen people that are really looking at this at a systemic level. They're looking at manufactured homes and whatever. We have some broken pieces in the conveyor belt of equity, like the condo legislation. You know, we can't get that condo legislation passed. So nobody's building condos. Essentially.

[00:50:16] I know I'm somewhat familiar with it. Yeah, essentially, you know, you have, if you're going to move into your first home, a lot of people are going to be able to afford a condo at $300,000 to $400,000. Well, the problem is, is the ambulance chasing lawyers go to all these new developments and they find three people that have a problem with their house and they form a class action lawsuit. And so the developer loses their shirt on it. And so unless you provide protections for developers in those things while trying to make sure people still have a good home, no one's building condos.

[00:50:45] And so the lobby for attorneys is coming in and beating that thing down every single time for there to be an environment where we can get that middle stock. But when you have the broken middle stock, there's no ladder to get into a $600,000 home. Yeah, but I'm confused because every time I talk to someone who's in the political world, they tell me how important it is to have more affordable housing. Why wouldn't they solve that?

[00:51:10] I mean, I sat with a state senator who admitted to me that the lobby was so hard on him that... Oh, tears coming down my eyes. I was a little bit, you know, astonished by his reaction. But, you know, it's just really sad that the attorneys are going to just make money off of this thing and people are suffering. So I think that has to be fixed. And we have to figure out how to make lower cost housing for sure.

[00:51:40] You know, the affordable housing movement is just a heavily subsidized movement. But why don't we think differently and say, let's get, like you said, a general stock where everybody can access equity in this state. We have the land. We have the smarts. Well, some of the... I mean, again, I'm not an expert on this, but, you know, my strong gut feeling, which tends to be typically more right than wrong, is in the name of making housing more affordable, we make housing a lot less affordable.

[00:52:09] We do things that just make it more expensive to, you know, develop housing. You gave an example that was a legal example. But even, you know, particularly here in Boulder, if someone's building new housing, the amount of extra that they have to spend on that housing is significant. And some of it is significant in the name of affordable housing. You know, so housing doesn't get built or the housing that does get built gets priced so high that, you know, maybe, you know, projects come here and there.

[00:52:38] But for every project that gets funded, there's five that don't get funded, which makes housing more expensive for anyone who wants to build equity in a house. And they're doing it under the name of affordable housing or under the name of protecting our environment. When some of the stuff they're asking people to do is like, okay, is that really protecting our environment? Or is that just adding another 10% to the house? I think I was interested in that when the red team kind of took over, you know, two years ago,

[00:53:04] they really campaigned on this affordability thing because they thought Biden had, you know, with inflation driven up prices and all that. And immediately the blue team in the last 12 months, they tore and they grabbed affordability away from the red team and made that their platform. I think Ezra Klein's book on abundance, like actually poked California in the eye and said, you guys want progress, but you've put so much bureaucracy, you can't do that.

[00:53:30] And, you know, within six months of that book, Newsom tried to create some new housing legislation. So I am kind of interested because I think everyone is looking at the affordability thing. And with the blue tsunami, as some are calling it, are they going to actually think about this in a strategic way to help with affordability? Because if they don't, I think you're going to have a counter swing happen. And they're going to have to really pay attention to it. So everyone's watching the affordability issue and housing hits us all.

[00:53:57] My fear right now is the younger generation is losing hope in the American dream, which has been our North Star forever, because they don't feel they can even access it. And we're talking like middle-class kids, so they can't get there. I'm going to say something a little controversial. And it's the younger generation's fault. Because to some degree, wake freaking up, younger generation. Your future is being destroyed not solely because other people are destroying it for you,

[00:54:23] but a lot of what you're doing as a younger generation is making your future get compromised. And you don't even, you've got to wake up and figure that out and build alliances with others. But the way they're behaving, what they're tolerating, what they're asking for, what they're expecting, is creating a problem for them. And the solution is not going to be socialism. It's just not going to be it. I mean, it doesn't take much work with Claude to say,

[00:54:51] where has socialism rescued people like us from a future that doesn't look as promising as it should? Yeah, my opinion is the rise in socialism is actually a reaction against a system that's not working. So they're grabbing the closest thing that has an alternative to that. I agree with that. But that's what I'm saying. Wake up. You're right. The system's not working as well as we all want it to work. But that ain't the solution.

[00:55:20] And if you go and hang your hat on that solution, you know, you're going to have, at some point, you're going to be the one who's, you know, lying in the bed you made. And good luck. Yeah. I really want to see hope restored in the fact that this country still provides the greatest opportunity for people. I do too. But I think accountability, the need for people to accept accountability is a big part of that hope being restored.

[00:55:49] I think too many people are wanting someone to give them hope. They want someone else to do the work of creating opportunity for them, someone else to do the work of solving why they should have hope. And I think a lot more people should be like, I need to be part of the solution. Whether I'm younger, you know, whether I'm, you know, wealthier, whether I'm less wealthier, whether I'm, you know, this type of person, that type of person. Going back to your earlier theme, it's all of our, you know, collective responsibility.

[00:56:16] I forgot what fine words you used to work together to make what we think of as the American dream real again. So I think this is, I mean, the tagline of the book is a community approach to solving poverty. Because right now, actually, there's an overemphasis on the public sector's role and what they can do. Because it's how people think that the levers of power primarily work.

[00:56:42] And we actually think that if we pull a policy lever, we're going to change things. And I say, you know, policy is the echo of a community who's already begun to care. It's the last thing that happens with the policy. We have to create a community that cares. And like I said, I'm not waiting on Washington to save us. I actually think as communities, we can come together. I think the best politics are local and we can help solve our own problems. All the books written on poverty are either personal memoirs or public solutions.

[00:57:11] I just felt there was a need for there to say, hey, we are stronger than we think. We can get together. And you're doing a lot of convening right now locally of people to say, let's help solve our problems as a state. And I think that more of that needs to be done because we can all help our neighbors and come up with this. And we need to be telling the electeds what to do, not them, you know, coming up with these, you know, copy and paste legislation from Louisiana and saying, okay, let's get this to work here.

[00:57:38] No, let's really come together and have a community approach that matches our culture. It matches our DNA as a state. And I think that's similar to what I said, if not the same, I just said it in more crude words like, you know, start taking more accountability for working together to come up with kind of reasons that the future will be better. Don't just, you know, point your fingers and say it's, you know, the boogeyman's fault and, you know, whoever you think the boogeyman is.

[00:58:05] And therefore we're going to rely on government to, you know, to solve our problems because the government ain't going to solve your problems. The government's going to make them worse. Yeah, I got into the work because I moved into Five Points and I moved in next door to a woman who was living in a Section 8 apartment and she had a daughter. Section 8 means what for the audience? It's basically the government's subsidized housing voucher system.

[00:58:29] So you can get a voucher and instead of paying $2,000 in rent, you can pay $1,000 in rent based on your income. And those vouchers are hard to come by, but, you know, she's in a subsidized duplex. And she was living in power. She's working at Walmart, changing oil in the auto bay, making $12 an hour after 12 years. Hard worker is the Walmart that I shop at. And I was like, she should be a shift manager on the floor. But she didn't really know how to, like, go to that level.

[00:58:58] She was just happy she had a job and she was kind of living her life. And so I started from, like, the neighbor up. You know, now, you know, she's graduated. She became a manager at Starbucks. Then she was the first black woman in Colorado to manage a FedEx store, became the seventh most profitable store. You know, then she bought her home. And now she manages, you know, 14 public storage facilities off of a laptop at home as a, you know, work from home job.

[00:59:26] And just took her kids to Cabo last week. So, like, that's how I'm... If she wants to be a guest on the Beer Wars podcast, I would love to hear her story. She's hilarious. So, yeah, you guys, she just did an episode with us on our podcast. If you guys want to listen to that, she's a fiery woman. What's your podcast? I didn't know you had a podcast. We just started two months ago. It's called From Poverty to Prosperity. And so we talked to usually a thought leader, a practitioner. We do a Poverty 101 series.

[00:59:54] And then we have a real story once a month of somebody who's actually been in Colorado and kind of moved up that full mountain to give people a picture of what could happen. So I say that to say I want to see the system work for my neighbor. So we went from kind of the ground up versus policy down. And so we just tend to have a different take on it. And we're seeing people make it. So we've had about 70 of our grads buy homes, 50 of them without our help at all.

[01:00:21] So I just want to keep leaning to that and say I'm surveying all of them right now. I'll say, how did you do it? Where did you get the down payment cap and all that? But like my foster daughter, she's now 35 years old. She got $40,000 down payment assistance from the Deerfield Fund out of Gary Community. She got $10,000 from a first bank, first time home buyer grant. And she got $10,000 from another nonprofit that was helping women with down payments. So she walked with a $60,000 down payment.

[01:00:50] But I guarantee you most women who are in low-income communities don't know that that money exists. So I think we have the resources. We have the know-how. We have the smarts. And we can get people into housing stock where they can start building equity. But, you know, that takes a relationship. That's part of that social contract again. But I will have people say to me, is that scalable, you know? Well, I do think one person helping one person all the way is a very scalable idea. But we have to care.

[01:01:18] Let's talk about kind of manufactured homes, like advanced manufacturing, smaller homes, kind of entry-level homes, but homes that someone, you know, can buy and own and how that may or may not be a scalable kind of solution to how to have a broader supply of entry-level housing that people can start with, you know, own

[01:01:48] so that they can sell and have equity value to grow into kind of bigger ones. Is that part of the solution in your mind? I would say it's in the top three solutions right now that everyone's looking at because the old manufactured homes, you would walk into those and you could tell it was a manufactured home. Now you can hardly tell and the quality has really gone up and you get your price point so far down. So I think... And I might be asking about something you're not, you know, deeply familiar with, but talk about the new techniques in manufacturing kind of the smaller homes. That's something you can...

[01:02:18] No, I don't. I don't. I know some people who are working on it who are highly interested. So I think if we got the condos and the manufactured home thing, you know, moving along, we would then provide this middle-of-the-road stock. I think it would bring prices down. How would you get the smaller manufactured homes moving along? What impediments are there to that or what would allow that to kind of flourish? I don't know. I just know there are a couple here in Colorado that are doing it and that people are looking at and saying,

[01:02:48] how can we really take that to... You don't even need to do it in Colorado. I mean, these things can happen anywhere. So I don't know on that topic. I'm more on the downside of the supply when they come through interested in... It just seems like, again, when I'm driving from Boulder to Denver and poke my head around, I see lots of opportunities that are in proximity to, you know, public transportation or in proximity to, you know, to being in downtown areas of Denver.

[01:03:16] Yeah, I think speed to market because I think to Ezra Klein's point is we so bureaucracize the process that it actually hurts business. It takes too long to get that thing sold, built and sold. So I think there's a lot of political will behind this right now. So I'm hopeful that we can solve some of these issues. Yeah, because to me, I mean, a big advantage Colorado has, hopefully we didn't just destroy that with the M87,

[01:03:42] but a big advantage is that we can attack, you know, affordable living, which starts with affordable housing in a scalable way if we really put our minds to it. And, you know, I'm a big fan of Mayor Mike Johnson, you know, as an example, and I know he cares deeply about this. You know, we should be able to work together regardless if you're in a, you know, red team, blue team, and somewhere in the middle to say, you know, that's a big part of the solution of affordability.

[01:04:10] And we are advanced here in Colorado of having kind of, you know, the space and land to kind of attack that. You know, let's just roll up our sleeves and make that work. And it was a market-based solution because I think if you look at the three sectors of the philanthropic sector, the public sector, and the private sector, I don't think, I think the philanthropic sector and the public sector can help, but it needs to be at a scale that the market's going to do it. So we've got to get to the price point so it's attractive to investors and developers

[01:04:39] to actually do this so we have the volume that we need to get the prices where they need to be. I agree. I mean, if the first thing you do when you want to, you know, solve it through what I'm describing is start to say, well, the government should have a big role in it. You know, the government should have a big role by removing the barriers, removing the regulation impediments of it, you know, making sure if there's laws that are staying the way that's happening, we address those. But if it goes further and says, and we're going to control it, okay, that's not going to be scalable.

[01:05:08] And two, you'll probably get in the way of it really happening. And the opportunity to really build equity value, you've probably robbed, you know, those who are going to live in those houses of that real opportunity because there's going to be a lot of, you know, strings attached on, you know, who gets to live there and under what circumstances and what happens if it goes up in value. You know, do you really get to benefit from that? If, you know, all that stuff just compromises the whole idea of it being a starter level home

[01:05:34] that you can build some equity value in and get ready to, you know, to prepare yourself for that next level up. Yeah. I mean, the average median income in this country is $75,000. If you had stock that was $250,000 to $400,000, you know, people can buy homes and build equity. And even it's a starter home. I mean, the first home I bought, you know, was a year out of college and it was, you know, 1,400 square feet and it was $96,000 in West Denver, you know.

[01:06:01] But three years later, I sold that thing and took the equity and rolled it into a new home. And I've been doing that ever since. And Colorado has been good to me. But the entry price point has become the biggest problem. So we need entry-level stock at scale. So right now, we just look at, for our graduates of our program, if they enter our… Well, entry-level stock at scale that's not government-controlled. Yeah, or long-term subsidized, right?

[01:06:28] Like, then we're just kind of like continuing to grow the public sector when, you know, we can let markets do this. Markets can move faster than the public sector. The speed to market for me is better. And then if it pencils out, right, now you've got… It wins. Everybody's a win, right? So, you know, so that's what I'm for. So we look at, for our families, everyone from like straight market purchases. We have people on two incomes that can buy a $500,000, $600,000 home.

[01:06:55] And then you've got over here, you've got the Habitat model, which is like a shared equity model. Like, you know, they can only get a certain amount of equity every year. And then there's some in between that are like, you know, do-gooders that come in and say, I'm going to build 20 units here and sell them at a discount because I care. We are just trying to become the experts at where that all is in the Denver-Boulder area so that our families can have access to what they can fit in their price points. But I would love to be able to plug into some larger plans because we, within four years,

[01:07:25] our families should be buying about 50 houses a year if our scale plan works. So, you know, that's a lot of houses that we're going to be needing to get families into. And I need people smarter than me on this issue really helping solve this so our families can, you know, achieve the American dream. Yeah. Let's talk about your organization. So we'd come back to that. So tell us about what your organization is, how long it's been around.

[01:07:51] You know, we could roughly guess at the mission, but do you have a tight mission statement? Yeah. Cross-purpose, we say we fight alongside our neighbors as they journey from poverty to prosperity by building three forms of capital, economic capital, relational capital, and spiritual capital. The economic capital is all we've talked about so far. The relational capital is the social capital and building a social network. Hugely important. Yeah. It's who you know. So we have models. In our model, we build social capital.

[01:08:19] And then the spiritual capital is they've got to believe in themselves. They've got to be healing from their trauma, all those kind of things. So we have a program that builds that. We have three programs, Launch, Leader, Legacy. Launch is a tech-enabled product that you can literally take on your phone in a homeless shelter. And you'll get six weeks of instruction. You build a plan to move up the mountain. You get a human coach who will coach you on your plan. If they graduate from Launch, they move into our six-month credential program called Leader.

[01:08:49] That's an on-site. Think of them going to school for about four or five months. And we do the soft skills. We now call those with AI, like human skills, like things that AI can't do. And then we put a micro-credential of AI on top of that. Then they move into their career track, so 15 different career tracks to get into middle skills jobs. Then they get placed into a job. They can't graduate until they actually get a job at $22 an hour or more. So it's an outcomes-based nonprofit model. They graduate from the Leader program. They can join the Legacy program.

[01:09:18] Six months after they graduate from Leader, they can join a three-year wealth building program where we put a $10,000 cash matching grant in a fund for them that they can use to do down payment on a home, match their 401k, or make a major purchase like an automobile to help them with their job. So it's a dollar-for-dollar match. Then they can get a two- and four-year degree for free. Then we have the business incubator as well. We also teach them on how to give back through a seven-week course on generosity.

[01:09:48] We find that a lot of people that are living in poverty are actually very generous people, pound for pound. And this then helps them even get trained in that. And they can then volunteer and take somebody else up the mountain as well through our mentoring program. So that's the three programs. We just, I'd say we're the concierge service for low-income families to achieve the American dream. So we're with families for between two years and ten years on their journey. It's like long-term love in the same direction to see people achieve the dream.

[01:10:17] And so then we've been going for 15 years, and we work with about 3,000 families a year. Most of them are in that first program. There's about 500 in the credentialing program, about 100 in the wealth building program. And we have four campuses around the Denver metro area that people can go to to get services. Where are the four? Englewood, Aurora, Denver, and Arvada. Where in Arvada? Right around 80th and Wadsworth. There's a strip mall there. We are the anchor tenant there.

[01:10:46] We've got about 17,000 square feet as a career center. Yep. Arvada is another area that I'm fascinated with because it's a big footprint. It's in a great geographic proximity. I mean, it's pretty easy to get to the airport, pretty easy to get to Denver, pretty easy to get to Boulder. It's got a really interesting kind of downtown area, and it's got a pretty broad demographic there, I would say.

[01:11:10] And it just seems like to do things like what you're doing, Arvada would be a great place. Yeah, our facility is about, if you look at, I say every community has a railroad tracks down the middle of it. You can find out who lives on which side of the tracks. And we were a little bit into more of the middle to upper income housing area where we found our location. And so we were about two miles outside from the railroad tracks, so to speak.

[01:11:36] And so there was a concern, would people of low income be able to navigate themselves to get to this property? And so, but we've had packed seats ever since we opened it three years ago. And so I love Arvada. My son actually works in homeless services for the city of Arvada. That's his career. And, you know, their homeless problem is far more manageable than Denver has on their plate. But I like the smaller communities because you can actually get together and say, hey, we can, I mean, I think they've now housed 57 of those 200 people.

[01:12:04] You know, you can start seeing this small, this change on a micro level. I think most changes local. And what we can do with a local model then is, I say, shine this really bright light and then let other people copy it. So our model of scale has just become the blue chip stock of nonprofit career development and wealth building and then just have people copy us like crazy. And what, how many team members do you have? About 100. About 100. So pretty, pretty sizable footprint. And you've been doing this since? 15 years.

[01:12:35] Well, congratulations and more importantly, thank you for what you're doing because with that size organization over that many years, the amount of lives that you are directly impacting has got to be. Yeah, we have 2,000 head of households now that are no longer in poverty making their own money. They've generated $200 million of their own wealth that they've earned. By 2034, we'll be at a billion dollars of earned money in their own pockets.

[01:13:01] And so for us, philanthropy is just a catalytic dollar to help them propel themselves into that. I want to say thank you to you too, Dan, because I think you've been bringing attention to the need for a healthy private sector, a center of innovation, and all of that. I view my spot in the ecosystem here is to provide that entry-level and middle-level talent to the emerging workforce, no matter the sector, so that we're ready to meet the demand of the hour and we can make this state great. Yeah, absolutely.

[01:13:30] And a lot of my focus has been on the private sector, but also we've got a sizable foundation that we put to work as well. So Boulder, Colorado, different demographic. What would an organization like you guys do if you were set up in the heart of Boulder? You know, I would do the exact same thing because Boulder has poverty. It's just more hidden.

[01:13:54] So, you know, Douglas County in the Denver Metro Area is the ninth richest county west of the Mississippi, or in the U.S., west of the Mississippi. I think it's the richest. And there's 12,000 people living below the poverty level in Douglas County. So Boulder does have a poverty problem. When Boulder talks about poverty, they always think of homelessness because it gets all the press and all the play and the Pearl Street stuff. But the homeless population is only 2% of the poverty population.

[01:14:22] The 98% that's living in poverty that might have a job, part-time job or whatever, they're underemployed, they're on some apartment building on the third floor with no food in the cabinets. That's what we would focus on because even in Denver, there's 52 nonprofits helping 10,000 homeless people, which is only 2% of the poverty population. And they're spending $80,000 to $120,000 per year per homeless person to really maintain homelessness.

[01:14:48] So we focus on the other 98% and say let's get them skilled up. So I think every community has an ecosystem where they have poverty, there's a need for labor, and there are companies that can employ people. So I would use the exact same model.

[01:15:02] Yeah, and on that third point, the companies that can employ people, I think that's where Boulder would bring a lot to the table because it does have really strong demand for that pay more than on average for jobs in the hospitality sector and the retail sector. And I think even though it's higher prices, so like... Higher wages is what I mean. Higher compensation is paid here. Now, I know cost of living is higher too.

[01:15:32] But there's a lot of jobs in the, you know, and certainly the retail, you know, I don't know if I'm using that word right. You know, I think of restaurants, I think of, you know, hospitality, probably those two more than traditional retail. There's just a lot of opportunity there in Boulder and it's hard to find people to staff those jobs. But those jobs do pay more than the same job would be in another community. Well, but I also think, you know, if you go to the mountain communities, they're really struggling.

[01:15:58] So if you get like Vail and Aspen and Summit County, they're struggling because nobody can afford to live there. So you've got these like trailer parks and Eagle or whatever. To your point though, Boulder, you don't have to live in Boulder to work in Boulder, right? There's a ton of land and other beautiful communities to actually live in that are nearby, right? So you have the opportunity if we can get that housing solution to create a socioeconomically integrated community that can, everybody can help each other.

[01:16:27] Well, if you've got someone who wants and is capable of leading a Boulder chapter and is willing to do it here where it could provide space, I would certainly, you know, be open to a conversation about how to be the launch, you know, sponsor of that. Yeah. I want to do it in a way that is tailored toward kind of, you know, this community, but in a way that's very consistent with what, you know, you just described. Thank you. Yeah, we'll consider it.

[01:16:57] Great. Anything we haven't covered that you would like to bring up? I aired in the beginning. I thought we'd find more areas where my idea of what we need to do and your idea of what we need to do. There'd been more space between the two. And I don't think we've come up with one of those. Well, when I walked into it, I was actually mentored by a businessman, not by a nonprofit leader. And I did come from the public sector. And so I know I put my kids into this neighborhood school in downtown Denver. I was broke as a joke.

[01:17:24] And this philanthropist came in and adopted the school. And he was a Denver guy. And he had run a couple dozen businesses and sold them. And he said, I want to see if I've turned around businesses. I want to see if I can turn on a school. And I just happened to be on the PTA of my kids' school because my school was in the third turnaround. And so we became friends. And he ended up giving our school money and asked me to help give the money away. And then he called me and said, hey, can you help me give some of my other money away?

[01:17:51] And so I went to work for him part-time while I was starting this work down in downtown Denver. But he just mentored me for seven years until he passed away. And he said, Jason, we're going to build an outcomes-based nonprofit, not an activity-based nonprofit. You know, heads in beds is fine. We'll count all those. But we actually want to say, are we seeing transformation happen in people's lives? So that mentorship deeply impacted the DNA of what we do. So I just started thinking of it.

[01:18:20] We say we operate at the heart of a nonprofit in the mind of a business. So that's kind of how I try to think about the work we do and say, you know, how can we make this all work? I have now come to believe that although I'm in the philanthropic sector, we're not going to solve the world's biggest problems. There's not enough capital there. We're like 4% of the GDP. We're going to need either public or private solutions. Yeah, but we'll become socialists. We'll at least quadruple that. I've heard that theme a lot.

[01:18:47] So I just want to, you know, so I just approach it with the mind of we need all sectors working together to make our communities thrive. And everybody plays a role. And I think different people get pushed out of that. But I think when we all come together, we can come up with a solution. So I actually think the convening that you're doing is some of the most important work. Because you need local leaders that say, hey, let's take ownership and accountability of our own community.

[01:19:16] Well, we can all do and see what we can come up with. And we can work together and we can collaborate. And we don't have to, like, find reasons to argue with each other over stuff we probably mostly agree with anyways. Just because, you know, we want to sound like we're this or sound like we're that. I mean, I think we could, you know, if we're talking and communicating and being, you know, listening as much as we're speaking,

[01:19:37] I think there's a lot more opportunity to solve the really hard problems than if we just get entrenched in kind of whatever our national political party tells us we should do and believe. And then if you have any ideas on how to, like, find someone who wants to proceed forward on building a grounds-up education model around the, you know,

[01:20:03] the certificates that taps into that source of funding from the government and can build something that is tailored toward that, you know, someone who really is capable of having an impact and wants to do it from here in Boulder, that's something I would be open-minded to. That would be beautiful. I mean, I think part of being on this podcast is just evangelizing that idea because Workforce Pell didn't actually come online until this summer, so it's brand new.

[01:20:29] And so I think you're going to see a lot of actors coming into it working on models that could work. So, you know, I'm talking to our, we actually do a 70-70. Our nonprofit hits those metrics, but we're not accredited. So I've been talking to a local university to say, hey, could we piggyback with you? You guys are accredited. We'll do the work, and then you can access Workforce Pell. How hard is it to be accredited? It's a pain. It's like two to three years to get accredited.

[01:20:56] And, like, the government would be like, hey, listen, we really want this to happen. Let's make two, three years be two, three days. They can't do that in the AI world. I can tell you're a private sector guy because that's how business thinks. That's how the market thinks, right? That's why I think America is the way it is because we see a market opportunity to go after it and try to create solutions and see if we can get it where we can scale it. I mean, that's what it needs. So there's an opportunity there for sure. All right. Thank you.

[01:21:26] It's been a lot of fun. I really enjoyed getting to know you and really appreciate all that you're doing. Thank you so much. Thank you so much. Privilege. Thank you for listening to this episode of The Bear Roars. Check out Stretch, the new song from Dan Caruso with music by Jason Mendelsohn, available now on all streaming services. If you enjoyed the episode, please like and subscribe on your listening platform. This podcast was produced by Loud Bear Productions and edited by Hannah Schmetzer

[01:21:52] with support from Kendall Weinberg, Alex Kim and Gibson Siegert. Thank you.